"Arguably the Club's most important signing in it's nine year history" is how local journalist and Radio Diamonds presenter Ian Addis opened his contribution to Garry Butterworth in the A-Z series in this Season's Match Day Programme, and there are few people who would take issue with that statement.

After being signed from Dagenham & Redbridge in the summer of 1994 Butterworth went on to play 368 times for Rushden & Diamonds, its a total that no one associated with the Club has ever come close to and, in all honesty probably never will. The £22,000 paid for Butterworth in 1994 was at the time widely considered excessive for a non-league footballer, but over the next eight years Butterworth repaid his fee many times over with numerous man of the match performances in midfield for the Diamonds.

Originally a central defender, sweeping behind Andy Peaks, Butterworth eventually moved up into midfield, where his commitment and skill earned him recognition as one of the finest player's outside the Football League and during his time in non league football Butterworth captained his country of many occasion's for the England semi pro team.

In his first Season at Nene Park Butterworth soon became a pillar of strength in the side and when he started the game at Gresley Rovers in October 1994 it was the start of a Diamonds record 104 consecutive starts. The last of these was against Hednesford Town at Nene Park in February 1997, seven days later this record was broken as an injury forced him to miss the Diamonds trip to Moss Rose to play Macclesfield Town.

During that run of 104 games Butterworth won the Maunsell Cup beating his old team Peterborough United in 1995 and a year later he captained the Diamonds in their Beazer Homes Premier Division winning Season. Butterworth remained an ever present during the Diamonds time in the Conference, only suspensions and injury forced Butterworth to miss any games. In the Conference winning Season Butterworth played over 30 time in the League helping the Diamonds to win promotion to the Football League.

After a decade of non-league football Butterworth stepped back into the Football League and never looked out of place. After numerous 'Butts Like' performances injury forced him to miss several games in then run into the play-offs. He returned to the side on the last day of the Season at the Shay to help the Diamonds into the play-offs in only their first season in the Football League.

The following Saturday Butterworth was the hero as his 25 yard strike earned Rushden a 2-2 draw at Nene Park against Rochdale in the first leg of the Division Three Play Off Semi Final, three days later Butterworth played his part in the 2-1 win at Spotland which secured Diamonds their place in the Play Off Final at the Millennium Stadium in Cardiff.

It was fitting that Butterworths final appearance for the Club was at the superb Millennium Stadium as Rushden & Diamonds took on old non-league rivals Cheltenham Town for a place in Division Two of the Football League. Despite a normal gutsy performance by Butterworth he ended up on the losing side as Cheltenham won promotion by beating the Diamonds 3-1.

Butterworth was granted a testimonial in August 2001 against a full strength West Ham United. Over 4,000 people showed their appreciation to a player who will always be one of the best ever players to have represented Rushden & Diamonds.

Season
League
FA Cup
Trophy
League Cup
County Cup
Total
1994 / 95
41
10
7
4
62
1995 / 96
42
6
1
4
53
1996 / 97
41
6
1
3
1
52
1997 / 98
28
2
2
1
1
34
1998 / 99
19
8
4
2
33
1999 / 00
41
6
6
1
2
56
2000 / 01
41
1
3
43
2001 / 02
35
2
1
38

Nominee
Votes
Glen Beech
57
Garry Butterworth
478
Darren Collins
391
John Flower
107
Kevin Fox
41